to teach logo

Traditional Holidays in Transition (advanced)

Different traditions

Carlos

Hey Carlos! How are you planning to celebrate Cinco de Mayo this year?

17:15

Hi Emma! I'm from Mexico, and we usually have big parades and lots of traditional food. What about you?

17:17

I'm from the US, and here it's more about parties and festivals, especially with Mexican music and food. I've heard that in Mexico, it's more about the historical significance, right?

17:19

Yeah, that's true! It's mostly about remembering the Battle of Puebla. My grandparents told me it used to be more about community gatherings and storytelling. What have your parents said about it in the US?

17:21

My mom said it started becoming popular in the US because people wanted to celebrate Mexican culture, but back then, it was mainly small gatherings with traditional Mexican dishes.

17:23

That's interesting! My family still keeps some of the old traditions alive, like making mole poblano. It's a special dish for this day. Do you have any special foods you eat?

17:25

We usually have tacos and sometimes tamales. My dad loves showing us how to make them. It's fun! Do you have fireworks there?

17:27

Not really for Cinco de Mayo, but some towns might do it. It's more about music and dance. How about you?

17:29

Some places here have fireworks, but mostly it's a big party vibe with dancing and mariachi bands. Are you doing anything special this year?

17:31

We're going to a festival and then having dinner with my family. It's always nice to be with everyone. What about you?

17:33

I'm going to a fiesta with friends, then having dinner at home. It's a great way to learn more about Mexican traditions!

17:35

Sounds great! I hope you have fun. Happy Cinco de Mayo!

17:37

Thanks, Carlos! You too!

17:39
Icon

How do you celebrate?

Read the chat conversation and talk about it in class: Do you celebrate this traditional holiday, and if so, how? Do you know of any other customs associated with this day?

Traditional holidays in different countries

The traditional holiday is celebrated differently in various countries. Can you correctly match the traditions?

Match the country with the tradition.

Traditional holidays in transition

Have a look at how traditions associated with the traditional holiday have changed over the course of several centuries.

Carlos, 1850

Carlos, 1850
Hola, my name is Carlos, and the year is 1850. Here in Mexico, we celebrate Cinco de Mayo to commemorate the victory at the Battle of Puebla. It's a day filled with parades, where I join my fellow townsfolk in riding beautifully decorated carriages through the streets. We dress in our finest charro outfits, and the air is filled with the sound of mariachi music and the cheers of proud Mexicans.
Carlos describes the early celebrations of Cinco de Mayo in 1850, focusing on the parade in Puebla and the traditional charro attire worn by participants.

Ana, 1920

Ana, 1920
Hola, I am Ana, living in the year 1920 in Mexico. Cinco de Mayo has evolved into a day of jubilation and dance parties in our bustling city of Mexico City. We embrace the spirit of the Roaring Twenties, donning flapper dresses and gathering with friends to enjoy lively jazz music. The streets are adorned with colorful decorations, and it's a time for celebration and socializing.
Ana describes the transformation of Cinco de Mayo celebrations in 1920, highlighting the influence of the Roaring Twenties style and the integration of jazz music into the festivities.

Luis, 2020

Luis, 2020
Hello, my name is Luis, and it's the year 2020. Though I live in Mexico, I often celebrate Cinco de Mayo in Los Angeles, where the festival has taken on a multicultural flavor. It's an opportunity to enjoy a blend of traditional Mexican foods like tacos and mole alongside contemporary culinary creations. The celebrations are a vibrant mix of music, dance, and cultural exchange, reflecting the diverse community.
Luis describes the modern Cinco de Mayo celebrations in 2020, emphasizing the multicultural aspects and fusion of traditional and contemporary elements in Los Angeles.

A different side of the tradition

Now read the newspaper article on the following page. What problem is being addressed here?

Environmental Consequences of Cinco de Mayo Festivities

As Cinco de Mayo celebrations grow in popularity, especially in the United States, the environmental impact of these festivities raises concern. The holiday, commemorating Mexico's victory at the Battle of Puebla, has become synonymous with vibrant parades, music, and food festivals. However, the aftermath of these events often results in significant pollution, particularly in urban settings where large gatherings are held. Cities like Los Angeles and San Diego, where the festivities are notably grand, face challenges with waste management and air quality due to increased vehicle emissions and discarded food packaging.

Cinco de Mayo performers at the White House Photo by Official White House photographer, sourced from Wikipedia

In Mexico, where the day holds historical significance, the celebrations are more subdued, focusing on historical reenactments and community events. However, the commercialization and adaptation of the holiday in the U.S. have led to increased consumerism that often overshadows the day's cultural roots. Statistics show that during Cinco de Mayo, sales of single-use decorations and themed party supplies soar, contributing to landfill waste.

Efforts are being made by environmental groups to promote eco-friendly celebrations. These include using biodegradable materials for decorations and encouraging public transportation to reduce carbon footprints. As awareness grows, the hope is to balance the festive spirit with environmental stewardship, ensuring future generations can celebrate Cinco de Mayo without compromising the planet's health.

Addressing these issues requires collaboration between festival organizers, local governments, and the community. By prioritizing sustainability, Cinco de Mayo can continue to be a day of cultural celebration while minimizing its environmental impact.

Icon

Criticism of traditional holidays

Although traditional holidays are celebrated often and with enthusiasm, there are also frequently negative aspects associated with them. Can you imagine what points might generally be criticized about traditional holidays?

Collect your ideas together in the class.

Discussion - Partner Work

Now prepare a discussion with role cards in partner work. One of you will take the pro position, and the other person will take the contra position. In addition to the arguments on the role cards, try to find other arguments for your position.

Maria (pro)

Maria (pro)
Hello, I'm Maria, and I absolutely love celebrating Cinco de Mayo! It's a wonderful opportunity to honor Mexican culture and heritage and share it with friends and family. The day is filled with vibrant music, delicious food, and joyful gatherings, bringing people together from all walks of life. It's a time to celebrate our roots and embrace the multicultural spirit it represents, especially in places like the United States where it promotes cultural exchange.
Maria shares her enthusiasm for Cinco de Mayo, highlighting the cultural celebration and the joy it brings through music, food, and community gatherings, emphasizing its importance in promoting cultural exchange.

Carlos (contra)

Carlos (contra)
Hi, I'm Carlos, and I have mixed feelings about Cinco de Mayo. While it's great to see Mexican culture celebrated, I worry that the day often becomes commercialized and loses its historical significance. The focus can shift from commemorating the Battle of Puebla to simply a day for partying. Additionally, the environmental impact of large festivals and the excessive consumption can be concerning. It's crucial to balance celebration with meaningful reflection and sustainability.
Carlos expresses his concerns about Cinco de Mayo, pointing out issues of commercialization, historical significance, environmental impact, and the need for a more balanced and sustainable approach to the celebrations.

Further arguments

Discussion

Now have a discussion with your partner and try to convince them of your opinion.

Icon

Discussion in class

Discuss the results of your discussion rounds in class: Which position was more convincing?

Now also ask yourselves the question of what relevance such traditional holidays still have today and discuss this together as a class.

Further questions

Choose one of the following three questions, and answer them in a short text.