Migration Part 1 - Pull and Push (Englisch - B2/C1)

Migration Part 1 - Pull and Push (Englisch - B2/C1)

Zielsetzung: Das übergeordnete Lernziel des Arbeitsblattes ist es, Schüler:innen das theoretische Konzept der Push- und Pull-Faktoren im Kontext von Migrationsbewegungen zu vermitteln. Anhand eines historischen Beispiels sie ein tieferes Verständnis für die vielfältigen Ursachen von Migration entwickeln und ihre fachspezifische Ausdrucksfähigkeit im Englischen schulen.


Inhalte und Methoden: Das Arbeitsblatt führt zunächst in die Definitionen von Push-Faktoren (z. B. wirtschaftliche Not, politische Instabilität) und Pull-Faktoren (z. B. Jobchancen, politische Freiheit) ein. Methodisch wird dies durch vier personalisierte Erzählungen („Migration Stories“) vertieft. Zur Wissensüberprüfung dienen Multiple-Choice-Fragen, gefolgt von einer reflexiven Essay-Aufgabe zur persönlichen Migrationsbereitschaft sowie der strukturierten Vorbereitung einer Debatte über die Signifikanz der verschiedenen Faktoren.


Kompetenzen:

  • Fach- und Sachkompetenz: Differenzierung und korrekte Anwendung der Push-Pull-Theorie auf historische Migrationsereignisse
  • Leseverständnis (Englisch): Erschließen von Detailinformationen und Fachvokabular aus englischsprachigen Sachtexten und persönlichen Erfahrungsberichten
  • Analytisches Denken: Identifikation und Kategorisierung von Migrationsursachen aus narrativen Quellen
  • Reflexions- und Schreibkompetenz: Verfassen eines englischen Essays zur Bewertung eigener potenzieller Migrationsgründe
  • Argumentationskompetenz: Systematische Sammlung und Strukturierung von Argumenten für eine fachliche Diskussion


Zielgruppe und Niveau: Englischlernende auf B2/C1-Niveau

TF
UI
VL
WO

109 other teachers use this template

Target group and level

Englischlernende auf B2-Niveau

Subjects

English

Migration Part 1 - Pull and Push (Englisch - B2/C1)

Definition of Push and Pull Factors in Migration

Push factors are conditions that drive people to leave their homes, such as economic hardship, political instability, or natural disasters. Pull factors are conditions that attract individuals to a new area, such as job opportunities, political freedom, or favorable climate.

Example: High unemployment rates in a region might push residents to migrate, while a neighboring area with abundant job openings serves as a pull factor.

4 migration stories

Seeking a New Beginning

In the 1850s, Ireland was plagued by the aftermath of the Great Famine, leaving many families in destitution. My family, like countless others, faced severe poverty and hunger. With the potato blight devastating our primary food source, we had little choice but to seek a better life elsewhere. America was seen as a land of opportunity, with promises of jobs and abundant land. We pooled our meager savings to afford passage on a crowded ship bound for New York. The journey was long and arduous, with cramped conditions and limited food. Despite the hardships, the hope for a new beginning kept our spirits alive.

Escaping Political Turmoil

The political climate in Ireland during the 1850s was tense, with ongoing struggles for independence from British rule. My father, a fervent supporter of Irish nationalism, faced constant scrutiny and danger. Fearing arrest, he decided to move our family to the United States, where political activism and freedom of speech were more accepted. We embarked on a treacherous voyage across the Atlantic, leaving behind the turmoil and unrest. The ship was filled with other families seeking refuge, and together we shared tales of our homeland, hoping for a brighter future in a country that promised liberty and democracy.

Seeking Religious Freedom

As Catholics in 1850s Ireland, my family experienced discrimination and oppression under British rule, where Protestantism was favored. The need for religious freedom was a driving force behind our decision to emigrate to America, where the Constitution promised the right to practice our faith without fear. We joined a group of fellow Catholics on a journey across the Atlantic. The voyage was fraught with uncertainty, but our shared faith provided comfort and strength. As we sailed towards New York, we dreamed of a place where we could worship freely and live without the fear of persecution.

Pursuing Employment Opportunities

With Ireland's economy in shambles after the Great Famine, finding work was nearly impossible. My older brother heard stories of America's booming industries and the need for labor, especially in cities like Boston and New York. Motivated by the promise of jobs and a chance to support our family, we set out for the United States. The journey was challenging, with the ship overcrowded and supplies running low. Yet, the thought of steady employment and the ability to send money back home drove us forward. As we approached the American shores, we held onto the hope of building a stable future.

Read the text and answer the questions.

A closer look

Reflect: Would you leave your home?

After learning about push and pull factors in more detail. What do you think weighs heavier - push or pull factors? Collect arguments for both sides.

Debate push & pull factors

Push factors are more significant because...

Pull factors are more significant because...

Sample arguments

  • Political instability and conflict drive people to leave their home countries.
  • Economic hardships, such as unemployment and poverty, push individuals to seek better opportunities elsewhere.
  • Environmental factors, like natural disasters or climate change, force populations to migrate.

Sample arguments

  • Economic opportunities in wealthier countries attract migrants seeking better living standards.
  • Access to higher education and advanced healthcare services can be a strong pull factor.
  • Political stability and safety in destination countries can attract individuals from volatile regions.